Elizabeth, Lady Scales:

The First Wife of Anthony Woodville

Susan Higginbotham

Anthony Woodville, Earl Rivers, married twice: the first time to Elizabeth Scales, the second time to Mary FitzLewis. This article discusses Anthony’s first marriage—a match that owed nothing to the royal alliance Anthony’s sister Elizabeth made.

Elizabeth was the daughter of Thomas, Lord Scales, and his wife Ismania, whose name is also spelled variously as Imania, Ismanie, and Esmania. Ismania was a daughter of a Cornishman by the name of Whalesburgh. [1] Described in Anthony’s inquisitions postmortem as 24 or older at her father’s death in 1460, [2] Elizabeth Scales was born around 1436. Besides Elizabeth, Lord Scales and his wife had a son, Thomas, who predeceased his father. [3]

Elizabeth Scales’s mother was among those ladies sent to escort Henry VI’s new bride, Margaret of Anjou, to England in 1445, and was one of her principal attendants, receiving forty pounds per annum in 1452-53. [4]

Lord Scales, born around 1399, had a long record of military service in France, where he remained almost continually from 1424 to 1449. He was made lieutenant-general of western Normandy in 1435; it is possible that Elizabeth was born there. [5] One source estimates his wealth in 1436 as 376 pounds per year. [6] At Rouen in 1442, Lord Scales had served as a godfather at the christening of the future Edward IV. [7]

During Christmas of 1445, Lord Scales was at his principal manor at Middleton when the mayor and council presented a nativity play there, with a cast that included a John Clerk as the Virgin Mary and a person with the surname of Gilbert as the angel Gabriel. [8] Nine-year-old Elizabeth would have been at an age to enjoy this thoroughly.

Elizabeth’s father had strong ties with the Woodville family from early on. Created a Knight of the Garter in 1425, Lord Scales successfully nominated Anthony’s father, Richard Woodville, Lord Rivers, as a Garter knight in 1450. [9] That same year, King Henry VI appointed Lord Scales, Lord Rivers and other men to put down Jack Cade’s rebellion. [10] Interestingly, when Richard, Duke of York placed his grievances before the king that autumn, Lord Scales and Lord Rivers were said to have accompanied him. [11]

However, Lord Scales remained loyal to Henry VI during the upheavals of the 1450’s. In the summer of 1460, when the exiled Earls of March, Warwick, and Salisbury returned to England with the intention of seizing power, Lord Scales and Robert, Lord Hungerford, held the Tower for the king. Besieged by the Yorkists, the forces inside the Tower shot guns and cast wild fire into the city, to the injury of “men and women and children in the streets,” as reported by the English Chronicle. [12] When the Yorkists, having defeated the Lancastrians at Northampton, returned to London with Henry VI in their power, Scales and Hungerford surrendered on July 19. [13]

Uncertain how he would fare at the hands of the Londoners, Scales, accompanied by three others, found a boat late that evening and rowed toward Westminster, with the intention of taking sanctuary there. Tipped off by a woman who recognized Lord Scales, a group of boatmen surrounded him, murdered him, and dumped his naked body at St. Mary Overy at Southwark. He lay there for several hours before his godson the Earl of March (later Edward IV) came upon the scene and arranged a proper burial for him. It was, as the English Chronicle noted, a “great pity” that “so noble and worshipful a knight,” who had served so valiantly in France, should meet such an ignominious death. [14]

Chroniclers seldom bothered to record the reactions of the wives and daughters of those slain during the Wars of the Roses, and they made no exception in the case of Elizabeth Scales. By the time of her father’s death, Elizabeth had likely already suffered the loss of her first husband, Henry Bouchier, the second son of the Earl of Essex by the same name. An August 27 letter in the Paston collection announcing his sudden death at Ludlow from an unspecified cause probably dates to 1458. [15] If any children were born to the couple, they did not survive.

Exactly when Elizabeth married Anthony Woodville is unknown, but contrary to what is sometimes claimed, it is beyond dispute that the marriage took place well before Anthony’s sister became the queen of England. The couple had certainly married before April 4, 1461, when William Paston reported mistakenly that Anthony, Lord Scales—the title that Anthony took in right of Elizabeth—had been killed at the battle of Towton. [16] Richard Beauchamp, Bishop of Salisbury, writing three days later, also reported that the dead included “Anthony, son of Lord le Ryver, who was recently made Lord le Scales.” [17]

Earlier, following the Lancastrian victory at the second battle of St. Albans on February 17, 1461, the Londoners had included Jacquetta Woodville, Duchess of Bedford, Anne Stafford, Duchess of Buckingham, and Lady Scales in a delegation sent to Margaret of Anjou to beg for mercy for the city. [18] Does “Lady Scales“ refer to Elizabeth or to her mother? Ismania had been prominent among Margaret’s ladies and would thus be a natural candidate for the task of negotiating with the queen, but it is not certain that she was still alive at this date; there is no indication that she held any lands in dower or jointure, as she would have if she had survived her husband. It may be, then, that “Lady Scales” refers to Elizabeth and that she had joined the Duchess of Bedford, Anthony’s mother, in the negotiations. This, of course, would push Elizabeth’s marriage to Anthony back to at least February 1461.

Whether Anthony and Elizabeth’s families helped bring the couple together, or whether the couple themselves initiated their marriage, is unknown. Elizabeth’s inheritance as Scales’s only surviving child was of obvious interest to Anthony, and his own status as the eldest son was of obvious interest to Elizabeth, but there is nothing to indicate whether personal attraction played a role in the marriage as well. Their age difference is not certain. Anthony was listed in his mother’s 1472 postmortem inquisition as being “of the age of thirty years and more,” which would put his birth date at around 1442 (to Elizabeth Scales’s probable birth date of 1436), but “the more” allows plenty of hedge room and leaves open the possibility that he was born earlier in his parents’ marriage, which took place by March 23, 1537. [19]

Elizabeth’s inheritance included lands in Norfolk, Cambridgeshire, Hertfordshire, Essex, and Suffolk. [20] The heart of the Scales estate was Middleton, near Bishop’s Lynn (later King’s Lynn). The town of Lynn often sent gifts of wine or fish to Lord and Lady Scales, whose minstrels also appear in the records. [21]

Lady Scales features in the household books of John Howard, who later became the Duke of Norfolk. In September 1464, Howard rewarded her messenger in the amount of six shillings and eight pence for bringing him a letter from Elizabeth. When with the king at Reading in November, Howard lent Elizabeth, who was also there with her husband, eight shillings and four pence to play at cards. The party moved on to spend Christmas at Eltham with the king; there, on January 1, 1465, Howard gave twelve pence to “my lord Scales chyld.” Anne Crawford has pointed out that the “child” was probably a page who was bringing a New Year’s gift to Howard from Anthony and Elizabeth, as opposed to the offspring of either Lord or Lady Scales, although Anthony did have an illegitimate daughter. [22]

Meanwhile, of course, Elizabeth Woodville, Anthony’s sister, had married Edward IV, the godson of Thomas, Lord Scales. Lady Scales was prominent among the attendants of her sister-in-law the queen. In 1466-67, like the queen’s sister Anne, who was married to William, Viscount Bouchier, Lady Scales received forty pounds per annum for her services (the same rate that her mother had received when serving Margaret of Anjou). She and Anne were the highest paid of the queen’s attendants; the next tier of ladies received only twenty pounds a year. [23]

In 1466, Anthony and Elizabeth engaged in a series of complex legal maneuvers, detailed in his inquisitions postmortem, to ensure that if Elizabeth predeceased Anthony without having borne him a child, the Scales estates would stay in Anthony’s hands instead of going to Elizabeth’s heirs. While this did have the effect of subverting the normal laws of inheritance, there is no reason to assume that Elizabeth was forced into the transaction by her husband or that she would have preferred that the land go to her rather distant cousins instead of to Anthony. [24]

When Edward IV’s sister Margaret traveled to Burgundy to marry its duke, Charles, in July 1468, Anthony Woodville served as her presenter. [25] Prominent among the English ladies accompanying Margaret to her wedding was Lady Scales. The marriage took place with all the ceremonial splendor one could expect of the Burgundian court. It certainly overawed John Paston, who wrote in a letter home, “And as for the duke’s court, as of lords, ladies and gentlewomen, knights, squires and gentlemen, I have never of none like to it, save King Arthur’s court. And by my troth, I have no wit nor remembrance to write to you, half the worship that is here.” The festivities featured jousting, in which Elizabeth would have seen her husband take a leading role. [26]

Anthony and Elizabeth’s return to England was soon followed by tragedy: in August 1469, Richard Neville, Earl of Warwick, having rebelled against Edward IV and taken the king temporarily into his custody, ordered the executions of Anthony’s father, Earl Rivers, and of his younger brother John—executions that were entirely illegal, as both Earl Rivers and John had been supporting the king that Warwick himself still recognized as his ruler. Anthony and Elizabeth now had  each suffered the murder of a father.

The continuing political upheaval led to Edward IV fleeing England in October 1470. A number of loyal supporters went into exile with him, including Anthony (now Earl Rivers). Where Elizabeth Scales spent the next few months is unknown. She may have joined her mother-in-law, Jacquetta, and Queen Elizabeth in sanctuary at Westminster, but I know of no source placing her there.

After Edward scored a Yorkist victory at Barnet, he returned to London briefly before marching out to encounter Margaret of Anjou’s forces. Anthony Woodville and the Earl of Essex, Elizabeth Scales’s father-in-law from her first marriage, were left to defend London from an attack by the Bastard of Fauconberg. Queen Elizabeth and her children were lodged in the Tower for their safety; perhaps Elizabeth Scales was with them.

Edward IV was back on his throne in May 1471, but Elizabeth Scales had little time to enjoy the peace that followed. According to Anthony’s inquisitions post mortem, she died on September 2, 1473. [27] She did live long enough to join in the festivities that took place when Louis de Bruges, Lord of la Gruthuyse, who had assisted Edward IV and Anthony while they were in exile, visited Edward’s court in September 1472. At a banquet in the queen’s chamber, Lady Rivers “sat at one mess” with the king and the queen, their daughter Elizabeth, the Duchess of Exeter, and Louis de Bruges himself. [28]

Anthony married Mary FitzLewis around 1480. He was executed on orders of the future Richard III at Pontefract on June 25, 1483.

In his will, written at Sheriff Hutton two days before his death, Anthony, having left the Scales lands to his brother Edward, asked that 500 marks be used for prayers for the souls of Elizabeth Scales, her brother Thomas, and the souls of all of the Scales family. [29] This provision has been interpreted as a slight by Lynda Pidgeon, who wrote that in his will, Anthony “makes no affectionate mention of [Elizabeth] or desire to be buried beside her” and that he appeared to do only the bare minimum to provide for her soul and those of others. Pidgeon concluded, “The will was business like: it met the requirements of his soul and those of his family and little else.... Perhaps he simply did not have feelings for anyone else.” [30]

Pidgeon’s judgment overlooks the fact that many wills of the period are businesslike documents, without sentimental effusions; it also fails to consider that Anthony, unlike testators expecting to meet a natural death or preparing for the eventuality of dying honorably in battle, was under the enormous stress of facing execution for a crime he most likely did not commit. Moreover, as he was about to be executed, he could expect his lands to be forfeit to the crown and would have to hope that arrangements would be made to pay his debts and honor his bequests. He was hardly in a position to make extravagant provisions for the dead. As it was, it does not appear that his will was ever admitted to probate during Richard III’s reign.

Anthony, possibly anticipating that he would be brought to London for the trial before his peers that was his right as an earl, initially asked in his will that if he died beyond the River Trent, he be buried in the chapel of St. Mary the Virgin besides St. Stephen’s College at Westminster, known familiarly as the Lady of Pewe. The Pope himself had recognized Anthony’s “singular devotion” to this chapel in 1476. [31] Contrary to Pidgeon’s surmise, Anthony’s failure to request burial beside Elizabeth Scales (whose burial place is not known) need not show lack of affection for her; it may simply indicate a strong devotion to the Virgin or to the chapel that took precedence over earthly attachments. Moreover, as a condemned man Anthony could not expect that the crown would go to the expense and trouble of bringing his body to lie beside that of Elizabeth, unless she had been buried at a convenient place for her husband’s burial. He had, in fact, little choice in where he would be buried, as he implicitly acknowledged at the end of his will, when having learned that he would be executed at Pontefract, Anthony asked to be buried there with his nephew Richard Grey, who was also facing execution, before an image of the Virgin Mary. [32] We can only guess at how close Anthony and Elizabeth Scales were to each other, but it is hardly fair to infer based only on this will that he was an indifferent husband.

In her thirty-seven years on earth, Elizabeth Scales lived through the violent deaths of her father, her father-in-law, and political upheaval; yet as with so many other women of her day, she left little behind to give us a clue about the woman behind her title. At the very least, it would have been nice to know what was in the letter her servant brought Lord Howard.

Endnotes:

1.  Myers, p. 182 n.1.

2.  TNA: C 142/1/36 (Cambridge); C 142/1/37 (Hertford); C 142/1/38 (Norfolk); C 142/1/39 (Suffolk).

3.  He is named in Anthony’s will, PROB 11/8. Printed in Pidgeon, p. 43.

4.  Griffiths, p. 486; Myers, p. 182.

5.  Castor.

6.  Wilkins, p. 194 n.17.

7.  Scofield, vol. I, p. 1.

8.  Lancashire, p. 227; Report on the Deeds and Records of the Borough of King’s Lynn, p. 88.

9.  Castor; Smith, p. 46.

10. Harvey, p. 81.

11. Griffiths, p. 707, n.108.

12. Davies, p. 96.

13. Scofield, vol. I, p. 92.

14. Scofield, vol. I, p. 92; Davies, p. 98.

15. Castor; Paston Letters, no. 574, part II, p. 175.

16. Paston Letters, no. 90, part I, p. 165.

17. Milan, no. 80, April 7, 1461,.

18. Kingsford, p. 173; Milan, no. 65, February 22, 1461.

19. C 140/42/49; Calendar of Patent Rolls 1436–1441, p. 53. A handwritten note by Robert Glover, Somerset Herald on a late fifteenth-century visitation suggests that Anthony may have been the Woodvilles’ oldest child. Visitations of the North, part 3, p. 58.

20. See n. 2; Pidgeon, pp. 30, 35.

21. Manuscripts of the Corporations of Southampton and Kings Lynn, pp. 224–25.

22. Crawford, Household Books, pt. I, pp. 281, 480–82; Crawford, Yorkist Lord, pp. 41–42, 156.

23. Myers, p. 288.

24. See note 2; Pidgeon, p. 35. The heirs in 1485 were John de Vere, Earl of Oxford, returned home after a long exile and imprisonment, and William Tyndale. Ross, p. 91.

25. Phillips, pp. 327, 329.

26. Paston Letters, no. 330, part I, p. 539. I have modernized the spelling.

27. See note 2.

28. Madden, p. 278.

29. PROB 11/8; Pidgeon, p. 43.

30. Pidgeon, p. 41.

31. Calendar of Papal Registers. 1476. 5 Kal. May. (27 April.) St. Peter's, Rome. (f. 99v.).

32. TNA PROB 11/8; Pidgeon, pp. 43, 45.

Sources:

Calendar of Papal Registers Relating to Great Britain and Ireland, Volume 13—1471–1484. Available online through British History Online.

Calendar of State Papers and Manuscripts in the Archives and Collections of Milan—1385–1618. Available online through British History Online.

Helen Castor, “Scales, Thomas, seventh Baron Scales (1399?–1460),” Oxford Dictionary of National Biography, Oxford University Press, 2004 [http://www.oxforddnb.com/view/article/24776, accessed 11 Oct 2012.

Anne Crawford, intro., The Household Books of John Howard, Duke of Norfolk. Gloucestershire: Alan Sutton, 1992.

Anne Crawford, Yorkist Lord: John Howard, Duke of Norfolk, c. 1425–1485. London: Continuum, 2010.

John Silvester Davies, ed., An English Chronicle of the Reigns of Richard II, Henry IV, Henry V, and Henry VI written before the year 1471. Camden Society, 1856.

Norman Davis, ed., Paston Letters and Papers of the Fifteenth Century, pts. I and II Oxford: Early English Text Society, 2004.

R. A. Griffiths, The Reign of King Henry VI. Gloucestershire: Sutton Publishing, 2004.

Henry Harrod, Report on the Deeds and Records of the Borough of King’s Lynn. London: Simpkin, Marshall & Co., 1874.

I. M. W. Harvey, Jack Cade’s Rebellion of 1450. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1991.

Historical Manuscripts Commission, The Manuscripts of the Corporations of Southampton and King’s Lynn. London: Her Majesty’s Stationery Office, 1887.

Charles Lethbridge Kingsford, Chronicles of London. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1905.

Ian Lancashire, Dramatic Texts and Records of Britain: A Chronological Topography to 1558. Cambridge University Press, 1985.

Frederic Madden, “Narratives of the Arrival of Louis de Bruges, Seigneur de la Gruthuyse, in England, and of His Creation as Earl of Winchester, in 1472.” Archaeologia, 1836.

A. R. Myers, Crown, Household and Parliament in Fifteenth Century England. London: Hambleton Press, 1985.

The National Archives (TNA)

Thomas Phillips, “Account of the Ceremonial of the Marriage of the Princess Margaret, Sister of King Edward the Fourth, to Charles, Duke of Burgundy, in 1468.” Archaeologia, 1846.

Lynda Pidgeon, “Antony Wydevile, Lord Scales and Earl Rivers: Family, Friends, and Affinity.” Part 2. Ricardian, 2006.

James Ross, John de Vere: Thirteenth Earl of Oxford 1442–1513. Woodbridge: Boydell Press, 2011.

Cora Scofield, The Life and Reign of Edward IV. London: Longmans, Green and Co., 1923 (2 volumes).

George Smith, ed., The Coronation of Elizabeth Wydeville. Gloucester: Gloucester Reprints, 1975 (originally printed 1935).

Surtees Society, Visitations of the North: A Visitation of the North of England Circa 1480–1500. Vol. III. Durham and London, 1930.

Christopher Wilkins, The Last Knight Errant: Sir Edward Woodville and the Age of Chivalry. London: I.B. Tauris, 2010.